Articles and commentary regarding the inner side of world events
January 9, 2006


                                  THE IMMIGRATION DEBATE

What do we take in?

How do we protect what's inside? 

What are boundaries for?

      The national debate concernng immigration looks at external factors that relate to economic enhancement or economic deprivation caused by the inflow of immigrants into this country. Some hold the view that wages that are taken by illegal immigrants could go to American workers.  Others hold the view that our economy benefits from hiring those who are willing to take substandard employment.  The question of immigration, however, is not an economic one, but a spiritual and moral one.  It relates to the picture we hold of what our country is about and what its purpose is.  The economics of immigration policy need to stand behind our moral commitment to fulfill the ideals of a nation whose founding charter included a vision of a republic that was open to all, where men and women could work for a living and better themselves, irrespective of what skills they possessed or where they came from.  This human betterment - the giving of liberty of choice and opportunity to as many as lived within her shores - was and is the destiny of America. 

      It is both the factor of economic restriction caused by a shrinking American labor market that is willing to work at low wages, combined with the factor of a class of wealthy entrepreneurs who want to make increasing profits from their corporate enterprises, which cause the loud debate over immigration - over the amount of dollars that illegal immigrants take out of the national economy in goods and services that others provide. 

      In reality, the wealthy of this country take much more out of the national economy than the relatively poor.  The wealthy are more responsible for usurping a higher portion of national wealth that could be redistributed in an equitable way than the poor, however great their numbers.  The wealthy, even if they make up only the top 1% or 2% of the population, use up a far greater portion of national resources, dollars, goods and services that others provide, than the very poor. 

     Additionally, the policy of opening our borders and our hearts to others is not just about economics.  It is also about the value of human life and the promise of this country in its founding vision to support and enhance each human life.  This promise is accompanied by an equally strong conviction, upheld throughout the history of judicial involvement in this area, that the rights of minorities would not be violated no matter what the reason for that violation.  It is for this reason as well, that the rights of those who have been compelled to enter this country illegally, must be protected. 

      America is a vast country and it it is founded on a vast vision.  Part of the erosion of principle that we see so greatly pervading the ideological landscape today, also occurs within the immigration debate.   To reduce the issue to a matter of economics reconfigures it so that the issue is no longer about people but about money, and not just about money, but about the desire of the very rich to stay in the same relationship with the pyramid of wealth as they have in the past.  This pyramid needs to be addressed, more than does the immigration policy of the United States need to be changed.  Opening our borders to immigrants who seek a better life will not limit the progress that American workers can make in their own lives, economically or in any other way.   What limits this progress is the greed that is rampant at the top of the economic pyramid, and also, as part of that greed, the increasing amount of outsourcing of labor that is taking place to markets abroad that offer very cheap labor pools. Rather than reject those who have arrived within America's shores to seek self-betterment and betterment for their families, it would be better to look at the economic issues involved with greed and outsourcing of labor as intimately connected with why this debate about immigration is happening at all.  The desire of the wealthy is to continue the practices that keep them wealthy while minimizing the risk that anything will need to be changed.  This is not the America of the founding fathers.  This is an America that has grown out of technicological advances which placed it at the head of developing countries in terms of what it could produce. It is an America in need of a recommitment to its founding vision.


*   *   *

See also:  In Focus: The Immigration Debate, A Project of the Institute for Policy Studies and the Interhemispheric Resource Center (1997).


The purpose of Light Omega is to bring us all into greater planetary consciousness with awareness of the suffering of others and with a willingness to remain awake to the challenges, dangers, and possibilities we face today.

Julie Redstone



They come, with nothing but the clothes on their backs,

      to cross a mighty ocean or a muddy river,

A vision of hope before them so compelling in its virtue

      that it is possible to risk life for it. 

They come, with children, and wives, and mothers hanging on their necks,

      burdened with responsibility, laden down as palpably

             as if those others were actually there in flesh,

             yet not needing them to be there,

For their pain and their poverty is always there, it never leaves.

Across the dusty desert plain they come

      and are turned back, or shot back, or mocked back,

And yet they continue to come like the relentless tide which surges forward

      that the sand cannot stop,

            nor the wind, nor the will of man.

This tide, fueled by hope, fueled by the promise of America,

      by the land of opportunity, the land of redemption,

      by the promise of a new beginning,

Rolls into shore in wave after wave

      of small rubber crafts that breach the open water,

In wave after wave of parched throats and dead bodies

      left in the sun to dry and to die from exposure,

In wave after wave of hearts willing to risk it all on one throw of the dice-           Will I make it?  Will I die?  Will I be turned back?

Only to set foot in the precious land,

Only to find a bed to sleep on, some work to do to pay for food,

Only to find a moment's rest amidst the grueling days and nights

      of passage.

Oh, America, you call your beloveds to you with dreams of the possible,   

Then send them away with the knowledge that it was just a dream,

      only a little dream - the thought of a child,

      not very real at all, no, not very real.

You call to you the homeless, the destitute, the needy,

      the impoverished, the persecuted, the despairing,

            the lonely, the hopeful,

But do not recognize that the call goes out

      even as your fences grow higher, and your borders become thicker,      

            and your memory of what it was all about grows dimmer.

Oh, America, land of opportunity, open door to the hearts of mankind,

Nourisher of the spirit,

Your call is being answered, your hope is being returned,

      your voice is being echoed by the waves of strangers

           who embrace your shores,

           who kiss the ground they find beneath their dirty and blistered feet -

This ground lifts them up beyond their shame, beyond their poverty,     

      beyond their transgressions,

Beyond every imaginable limitation of heart and soul

To a place that is higher in which hope is reborn.


*  *   * 


The present series of newsletters will come to you on a less regular basis than previously, so please look for the messages in your mailbox and please share these newsletters with whomever you wish to.

I look forward to receiving your comments on this

or other newsletters at:

To view back issues, click here.

To subscribe, click here.


Light Omega Home Page Signup A-Z Index Archive